Thinking About Jane
Yes, I am one of those annoying people that calls Jane Austen by her first name.
So I was thinking about Sense and Sensibility. Something I had never really thought about before: Edward Ferrars really isn't better than Willoughby.
I mean, Edward is engaged when he meets Elinor. Willoughby is free. Edward is beholden to the whims of his mother, Willoughby is beholden to his aunt. Edward knows he is not free but moves forward with his relationship with Elinor dishonestly. Willoughby lets Marianne believe they have a future.
So why does Edward come out of this smelling like a rose? Is it because Marianne acts like a tragic heroine and Willoughby encourages her excesses? But this behavior is Marianne's choice. She could choose to be more circumspect.
Is it because when confronted with the two women in his life Edward acts like someone in the hotseat whereas when Willoughby is confronted he acts as though it was all in Marianne's head?
I'm thinking we like Edward better because of Elinor's reaction to him. It is Marianne's excesses that drive us to dislike Willoughby. Elinor loves as deeply as her sister, is pained as deeply as her sister, but in her grace there is transcendence. We are turned off by Marianne's extremism and therefore turned off by Willoughby. So the main characters' actions and reactions tell the reader how to feel.
So I was thinking about Sense and Sensibility. Something I had never really thought about before: Edward Ferrars really isn't better than Willoughby.
I mean, Edward is engaged when he meets Elinor. Willoughby is free. Edward is beholden to the whims of his mother, Willoughby is beholden to his aunt. Edward knows he is not free but moves forward with his relationship with Elinor dishonestly. Willoughby lets Marianne believe they have a future.
So why does Edward come out of this smelling like a rose? Is it because Marianne acts like a tragic heroine and Willoughby encourages her excesses? But this behavior is Marianne's choice. She could choose to be more circumspect.
Is it because when confronted with the two women in his life Edward acts like someone in the hotseat whereas when Willoughby is confronted he acts as though it was all in Marianne's head?
I'm thinking we like Edward better because of Elinor's reaction to him. It is Marianne's excesses that drive us to dislike Willoughby. Elinor loves as deeply as her sister, is pained as deeply as her sister, but in her grace there is transcendence. We are turned off by Marianne's extremism and therefore turned off by Willoughby. So the main characters' actions and reactions tell the reader how to feel.
sleepy
contemplative
bouncy
chipper
sick
lethargic